Showing posts with label crime and punishment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label crime and punishment. Show all posts

Monday, January 10, 2011

Targeting Rep. Gabrielle Giffords

We've been hearing a lot about how Palin's political machinery is responsible, in some way, for the attempted assassination of Rep. Giffords and the murder of 9 people on Jan. 8, 2011. The idea is that conservatives have consistently used a rhetoric of "targeting" -- a visual and linguistic rhetoric -- when speaking about defeating Giffords and others in the elections. Others have responded -- I believe it was an article in the New York Times -- that liberals frequently use this same rhetoric to talk about defeating conservatives. The point then is that the rhetoric of targeting is not simply a partisan phenomenon, but rather marks contemporary rhetoric in general, especially since 9/11.

This is argued in Samuel Weber's 2005 book Targets of Opportunity: On the Militarization of Thinking (you can read it on Google). Part of his point is that targeting is not "originally" a military phenomenon, but rather has to do with a more general attempt to respond to a singular event by focusing on it and extracting it from its context so that the event can be localized and hence controlled. Targeting therefore always assumes that it is possible to control the uncontrollable, simply by placing it in real or metaphorical cross hairs. It is in fact the very essence of what it means to act as an autonomous subject and, one might add, as a political subject. As if to say: I, the sole agent of my actions, will execute this precise act in a controlled manner, in order to produce a controlled effect. And to a certain extent, that's exactly what targeting does. Weber: "Targeting thus constitutes the condition of all execution, the execution of acts no less than that of judgments and sentences, such as the death-penalty. Every such execution, as targeting, is potentially and tendentially lethal, for by taking aim at its object, it isolates that object from its relation to its surroundings, removing everything that might distract its aim from the place it seeks to secure: that is, to occupy and to appropriate" (105).

The problem, of course, is that targeting rarely hits only that which one believes one is targeting. Collateral damage always takes place, that is, things are damaged that only happened to be sitting nearby, collaterally. And this means, in turn, that targeting rarely targets in a way that is fully controllable by an autonomous and fully intentional agent or executor. If collateral damage can happen, if it is always a risk, then this means that collateral damage is not simply accidental but rather remains as an essential part of any act of targeting: to target, to isolate an object from its surroundings, is always potentially to hit a non-target (something surrounding the target, something collateral).

And this is perhaps the generalized phenomenon that we've been witnessing in the last few days, perhaps the last few years: an attempt to control politics through targeting, which inevitably leads to collateral damage, what Sheriff Clarence Dupnik called "consequences." Palin et. al. targeted Giffords politically, but this act of targeting went beyond their intentions and ended up hitting her physically. The "lone gunman" Loughner targeted Giffords physically, but ended up hitting others as well. This is not an accident; this is what happens when people are targeted.

This problem of targeting also gets to the question of whether this act can be called "political." On the one hand, we can (and should) be indignant about the fact that the American media assumes that the assassination of a politician in Pakistan is clearly political (even though the assailant is clearly deranged) while the media here routinely denies the political nature of the same type of act that takes place in the United States of America. On the other hand, the problem of targeting shows us that this act has always been political, since this attempted assassination is infected by (though not necessarily produced by) the political targeting that was happening in "mere" rhetoric.

I therefore put "lone gunman" in quotes, because Loughner was not alone when he targeted Giffords. While it was certainly only his eye that was focusing on the U.S. Representative in that moment, the cross hairs had already been placed there by others, and will be placed there by others in the future as this case gets told and retold in the media and in the courts. At this point, to focus on the attempted assassination of Rep. Giffords is to target Giffords, and the question now becomes an ethical one as well as a political one: what does it mean to target Giffords now, after she has been the target of so many others?

Saturday, January 17, 2009

Round Up

In this round up: games for two, awesome music blog, starting seeds, IKEA cookery, Girl Scout cookies, consumer journalism, personal finance in the end of days, greenhouse gas emissions, nature makes you smarter, the U.S. Sentencing Commission, California's sentencing sucks, Teague retroactivity, kick off your shoes, Habitat for Humanity's ReStore, and another Shepard Fairey poster.

Also, I've added a few more resources to my page of parenting resources.

Bob and Rebecca gave David and me Carcassonne for Hanukkah 2008. We actually played it at least once a night for the first two weeks after we received it. Now we're sort of in a gaming frame of mind. Which makes the AskMeFi discussion of great games for two people particularly timely.

Carrie Brownstein, one of the members of the awesome band Sleater Kinney, has her very own music blog via NPR called Monitor Mix. Definitely worth a listen.

As discussed in my post about Mark Bittman's recommendation to use fresh basil and parsley, I'm planning a minor expedition into the world of container gardening this year. Re-Nest has a nice post about when and how to start your seeds inside, including a handy link to Organic Gardening's article about when to start seeds.

Michele Humes over at Serious Eats did an incredible job assembling the food available at the grocery department of IKEA into some pretty impressive dishes. She was refreshingly frank in her review.

If you like the pronounced flavor of oily fish like sardines and mackerel, you'll probably enjoy this hors d'oeuvre. If you don't, you'll probably gag.
I'm totally serving Lingonberry-Glazed Sausage Bites with Crispy Onions at my next dinner party.

Erin Zimmer, also at Serious Eats, reminded us that it is Girl Scout Cookie Time and also provided a few links to recipes for homemade versions.

The Consumerist, which was recently purchased by the Consumers Union, posted an interesting summary of an article by Trudy Lieberman in the Columbia Journalism Review about the death of true consumer journalism.

The Consumerist also posted a list of good habits for personal finance a deep recession. Much of it is quite helpful, though, "You should have an emergency fund, with 3-6 months of living expenses in a savings account," seems utterly unrealistic to me. Am I wrong?

Jon Rynn posted a summary of his findings about the sources of greenhouse gas emissions over at Gristmill.

And just when you thought all environmental news is depressing: The Blue Marble reports that a study showed that walking in nature for as little as 30 minutes, regardless of whether you enjoy the experience, helps improve memory and attention by 20 percent.

The U.S. Sentencing Commission is holding public hearings and initiating a practitioners' advisory group. The first public hearing is in Atlanta, Georgia, February 10-11. So if you have "any suggestions regarding changes to the Sentencing Reform Act and other relevant statutes, the federal sentencing guidelines and policy statements, and the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure that," you think, "will further the statutory purposes of sentencing," you should totally go. Via Prof. Berman's sentencing blog.

Prof. Berman also crowned California as the most dysfunctional state in terms of sentencing.

If you're one of those post-conviction practitioners who loiters around here when you should be working on your responses to habeas petitions, check out Christopher N. Lasch's forthcoming article on Teague retroactivity from Yale's American Criminal Law Review as summarized by Prof. Berman.

We have a friend who's a doctor and has a small child and is a big stickler about taking shoes off in the house. We thought he was just OCD, or suffering from PTSD due to his internship at Grady Memorial Hospital in downtown Atlanta. But according to Re-Nest, there are 37 different reasons he might be perfectly sane about this whole shoe taking off thing.

Consumerist recommends something my friend Julia recommended long ago: head to Habitat for Humanity's ReStore for material for your next home project. There are two in Orange County, California, at 12827 Harbor Blvd in Garden Grove and 2200 S Ritchey St. in Santa Ana. There are two in Baltimore, Maryland, at 505 Kane St., and 1300 N Fulton Ave. There's one in Richmond, Virginia, at 1901 Roane St. There's one in New Port Richey, Florida, at 3531 Grand Blvd. I think that covers our top reader locations.

Birdie Loo of Dear Ada fame loves Shepard Fairey's poster for the animal adoption group Adopt A Pet and so do I. It explores many of the same themes addressed in my post-election patriotism furrday post.

Click here to see the rest of this post...

Monday, December 15, 2008

Writing as Punishment

When your students complain that your assignments are punitive, now they have a little precedent to back up their argument. A superior court judge in New Jersey ordered two young men, who were convicted for going along with the marijuana growing plan of their roommate, to read and write essays about

Judgment at Nuremburg, a 1957 play by Abby Mann that was adapted into the Academy Award-winning 1961 film about Nazi war criminals brought to justice for their crimes against humanity. The significance of the assignment is that the war criminals claimed to just be following orders,
just as the two young men said they were following their roommate. Via Prof. Berman's Sentencing Law and Policy Blog.

Saturday, November 22, 2008

Round Up

In this round up: embroidery patterns meet technology, bag making tutorials, underbritches, french seams and hand-rolled hems, collages, decoupaged ceilings, stenciled cement, space-aged chicken coop, sheep, recycle Brita filters, recycle CDs, wash fruit & veg, persimmons, Obama and food politics, Obama and criminal justice, and a funny post title.

SharonB, formerly of In A Minute Ago, currently of Pin Tangle, shared an online resource for vintage embroidery patterns, J. F. Ingalls, which is cool. But what's even cooler is she links to two tutorials from the same resource about how to use GIMP to turn illustrations from the catalog into usable designs AND to enlarge a design without getting the fuzzies, i.e. it shows you how to turn images into a vector images.

I have this very specific drawstring bag project in the sourcing materials phase that might be helped out by one or more of the bag tutorials collected by KathRed over at WhipUp.

I'm not the only one interested in Angry Chicken's underthings. WhipUp mentioned her unmentionables and collected a few more panty production links.

I'm not remotely interested in making a french scarf, but I am interested in learning how to sew a french seam and how to sew a hand-rolled hem both of which Colette explains clearly with beautiful pictures. Via WhipUp.

I'm in love with impactist's photos of cut paper collages over at Design*Sponge.

When I was in my extreme fish-themed bathroom phase I would have been all about decoupaging my bathroom ceiling with printouts of fish after seeing this awesome DIY decoupaged ceiling project over at Design*Sponge. I'm over fish in bathrooms, but I wonder what else I could do.

Design*Sponge has a Before & After showing some pretty impressive stenciling on a cement patio. This has totally set my mind racing about ways to spruce up our back patio with paint.

Yanko Design featured a very modern looking chicken coop via Re-Nest. I can't actually find any information about whether it is in production. C'est la vie. It might look more sleek in the backyard than the Eglu, I found in June also at Re-Nest, which appears to be for sale in the U.K.

Of course we all know chickens are the gateway-livestock to sheep. Serious Eats posted about people becoming sheep farmers and artisanal cheese makers . . . a dream I know at least a few of us share.

According to Re-Nest, the Take Back the Filter campaign, which I mentioned back in May, has succeeded! So start setting aside your used Brita filters because starting in January you can drop off filters at Whole Foods Markets or mail them in.

Did you know you can recycle CDs and DVDs? It's true, according to Re-Nest.

Re-Nest suggests a novel & eco-friendly method to really clean produce.

To supplement my persimmon post, Re-Nest has more information about persimmon buying and consuming.

On the food politics front, Gristmill has been closely watching the Obama transition team for signs about the future of the Department of Agriculture and other key food-policy posts.

In other political news, Prof. Berman shared his thoughts on what presumptive Attorney General Eric Holder might do in terms of criminal justice and sentencing. He also shared his criminal justice wish list for the incoming Obama administration. He zooms in on the criminal justice section of the a new publication from the Center for American Progress Action Fund, entitled "Change for America: A Progressive Blueprint for the 44th President."

Lastly, The Most Hilarious Blog Post Title if You Think Like a 12 Year Old Boy: Dingell Waxed

Click here to see the rest of this post...

Wednesday, November 19, 2008

Do I Have 4 Cents?

Do you want to give your two cents to President-Elect Barack Obama? I've already posted a few opportunities to pool your two cents with like-minded organizations. Here are a couple more: Amnesty International and Families Against Mandatory Minimums.
Amnesty International has an app that helps you write a letter to President-elect Obama (requires registration) asking him to demonstrate his commitment to justice by:

  • Announcing the timeline to close Guantánamo
  • Issuing an executive order to ban torture and other ill-treatment as defined under international law
  • Ensuring that an independent inquiry into the USA’s detention and interrogation practices in its “war on terror” is set up

Fascinating that both NOW and Amnesty International emphasize the individual letter writing format rather than the petition format. I wonder if these time-tested NGOs have found letters demonstrably more effective than petitions.

Families Against Mandatory Minimums has a partially editable letter to President-elect Obama stating:
Congratulations on your victory. As you now prepare to take office, I am sure you are assembling a policy agenda for the beginning of your term. I urge you to include federal sentencing reform as a high priority for your administration.

As a concerned citizen and member of Families Against Mandatory Minimums (FAMM), I believe that the one-size-fits all nature of mandatory minimum sentences undermines a basic principle of American justice - that the punishment should fit the crime and the individual. As you develop your criminal justice agenda, please keep in mind these key facts about mandatory minimum sentences:

- Mandatory minimum sentences prevent the courts from considering the facts of each case or the individual's role. For example, only the weight and type of drug, or the presence of a firearm during a felony offense, determine the length of a mandatory minimum sentence. Judges cannot lower a mandatory minimum sentence because of the circumstances of the case or a person's role, motivation, or likelihood of repeating the crime.

- Mandatory minimum laws often punish low-level defendants more harshly than those who are more culpable. Those with higher levels of involvement in an offense that carries a mandatory minimum often have information to give prosecutors in exchange for a sentence reduction. However, people at the periphery of these cases - for instance, drug couriers, addicts or relatives of drug dealers - often have no information to give to prosecutors and end up with a longer sentence.

- Public support for mandatory minimum sentences has waned. According to a recent poll commissioned by FAMM, 59 percent of Americans oppose mandatory minimum sentences for nonviolent offenders. And fully 78 percent of Americans agree that courts - not Congress - should determine an individual's prison sentence.

- Mandatory minimum sentences are the least effective means of reducing drug use and sales. At a time of financial crisis, our sentencing policies should be cost effective, not just costly. Treatment of substance abusers is eight to nine times more cost effective than long mandatory sentences, according to the RAND Corporation.

I believe the time has come for a new approach on federal sentencing issues, one that upholds the traditions of individualized justice that Americans hold dear. I sincerely hope that you will give mandatory minimum sentencing reform the attention it deserves.

Thank you for your attention to this issue. I wish you the best of luck during your transition and beyond.


Click here to see the rest of this post...

Monday, November 03, 2008

Hoodwinking Slate Flier



Originally this post was going to be titled "Too Late" and focus on (1) the fact that I didn't get this mailer until after I'd mailed in my ballot and (2) the differences between who and what I voted for and the slate presented in this flier. Then I did the standard blogger's due diligence: I googled the name of the organization that sent the flier "The Team for Democratic Voters." Up popped this handy article from The Sacramento Bee, "Political Mailer Misleading."

Apparently "The Team for Democratic Voters" is a for-profit company from whom candidates and proponents of propositions can pay to be included on mailings designed to appeal to members of a particular party. Apparently something similar is happening with misleading fliers aimed at Republicans.

Here in Fullerton, City Council candidate F. Richard "Dick" Jones and Superior Court Judge candidate Kermit Marsh felt that deceptive campaign mailers were worth their campaign's dollars. Thank goodness I didn't vote for either of them. In fact, based on my research, F. Richard "Dick" Jones was the first candidate that I crossed out to indicate "Do not vote for this bad guy." And did the Democratic Party of Orange County even endorse him? No. The OC Dems endorsed who I voted for: Karen Haluza and Sharon Quirk. (Click here to see my comprehensive Fullerton voting guide - which is solely my own doing and is in no way supported by any political party.)



And you know what really gets my goat about Kermit Marsh's blurb on the mailer? It says, "Opponent: Long-Time Criminal Defense Lawyer." (A) Like that's a bad credential for a superior court judge. (B) His opponent, Debra Carrillo, is currently a Deputy District Attorney, so she's not exactly a hug-a-thug. If anything, having been on both sides of the criminal justice bar will make her a fair-minded judge. Oh, yeah, and by the way, if you want to know who the Democratic Party of Orange County actually endorsed in this race: Debra Carrillo.



But the first clue I had that something was rotten in Denmark was that the mailer suggested I vote yes on Proposition 10, which is pretty well known as one natural gas billionaire's personal proposition of doom (though, interestingly, the OC Dems were neutral on it). Also the criminal justice propositions the mailer advocated were internally inconsistent. You probably would not vote yes on Proposition 6 (Police and Law Enforcement Funding/Criminal Penalties and Laws) and Proposition 9 (Criminal Justice System/Victims' Rights/Parole Initiative Constitutional Amendment and Statute) AND vote yes on Proposition 5 (Nonviolent Drug Offenses/Sentencing, Parole, and Rehabilitation).

What do I have to do to get a proposition banning misleading political mailers on the next ballot?

Click here to see the rest of this post...

Monday, October 20, 2008

Round Up

In this round up: hipsters in NYC, everyone deserves defense, color IQ, Denyse Schmidt quilts for Obama, Ikea fabric, backyard chickens, alternative dog poo disposal.

P.S. I've added a new link or two to the Color Theory Index.

I'm going to NYC on my east coast tour in a week and I am, perhaps not shockingly, too cheap to get a hotel room. So I'm staying with my friend Elisa and her roommate. I am SO not cool enough.

Over dinner at my brother's wedding, my mother's significant other decided to drill me about who I would defend if I were a criminal defense attorney. My mom's S.O.'s radical inappropriateness aside, my answer was something like Peter Keane's piece in the This I Believe series on NPR: Everyone Deserves Defense.

Interested in quantifying your ability to arrange color? Got things to do that you really don't want to do? Need to look busy on your computer without actually doing anything too taxing? Test your color IQ via True Up. Beware: the graph at the end comparing your results to other folks of your age and gender is completely f--ed. Certain mathematicians, who we'll just call "Bob" for the sake of argument, would call said graph an example of innumeracy.

Check out dogged's post about an eye-bending Obama quilt designed by the very popular quilt designer Denyse Schmidt to be auctioned off to benefit the Obama campaign. Via Dogs and Laughter.

I am seriously contemplating Ikea's $5.99 per yard Inger fabric. It's 59 inches wide, so it would make a great backing fabric. And I've got some projects that are looking for some oversized black and white prints to be overdyed, so this might be just the thing. The only thing giving me pause is the extremely low thread count of some of the Ikea cloth goods I've purchased in the past. I better go check these out in person. And maybe have some Swedish meatballs and a cinnamon bun while I'm at it. Via Domino via Design*Sponge.

More support for backyard chicken coops via the Organic Consumers Association.

Another alternative to plastic grocery bags for dog waste disposal: Skooperbox Biodegradable Poop Scoop Boxes via Re-Nest.

Click here to see the rest of this post...

Tuesday, October 07, 2008

Round Up

In this round up: cake not from a box, bread not from a box, churros not from a box, water from thin air (aren't you glad I didn't say "not from a box"?), save the planet by drinking less booze, ironing board cover, comic book shop, vote YES on Prop. 5

I made my own frosting the other day for a belated birthday cake for David. The frosting went over really well. Now I'm contemplating making a whole cake from scratch. Not Martha linked to this awesome recipe (I haven't tasted it, but I know it's awesome because one of the steps is "Wonder at your own glory."), so now I want to try it. I wonder if almond extract would have the same effect on David as an actual almond? I.e., should I substitute vanilla extract or risk turning my husband into The Exorcist baby?

In other, less nauseating, from scratch news, I baked my mom's recipe for yeast rolls for the first time the other day. Awesome. I had the yeast on hand because I was fantasizing about making challah after reading two weeks ago's Sunday New York Times Recipe Redux. Now CHOW has to tempt me with these new and short-cuttier no-kneed bread recipes from the New York Times. But they require a casserole dish with a lid to bake, which I don't have. Might have to go on another bakeware binge at Bloomies.

And how crazy is it that I had Mexican Chocolate Pot de Creme with churros in La Jolla this weekend on the eve of the Sunday New York Times publishing a recipe for churros?

I love the idea of a dehumidifier that produces potable water, via Re-Nest, but I totally wish this worked indoors instead of outdoors. Though if everyone in Georgia used this, that place might be a lot more comfortable to hang outside. Of course, they're in a drought, so it's kind of selfish to drink the humidity that could be made into a helpful cloud.

Mother Jones reports a study describing how food manufacture contributes to global warming and what specific changes to your diet to make to reduce your menu's greenhouse emissions. One suggestion: eliminate "'unnecessary' foods with little nutritional value like alcohol, which it says contributes 1.5 percent of emissions from food." Check. Another suggestion: eliminate chocolate, another "unnecessary" food. Now that's just crazy talk. But here are some other suggestions that some might consider less insane:

using microwaves more often, covering cooking pots for efficiency, shopping on the Internet, and accepting "different notions of quality"—presumably eating bruised peaches.


I have needed to recover my ironing board for so very very long. It's not as simple and intuitive as you'd think. Whip Up posted a link to a tutorial by Make Something. It's in a very pretty photo format. It doesn't seem to mention padding, so I might have to modify it so I can add a layer of Insul-bright batting. Without the padding the pattern of the metal of the ironing board comes through onto my fabric.

Unfortunately the coolest name ever for a comic book shop is already taken, The Secret Headquarters. But I think Bob's dream comic book shop could certainly be informed by the design aesthetic of The Secret Headquarters. Via DesignSponge.

I had the harrowing experience of learning that my in-laws had plain not voted on ballot referenda in their home state because the wording was so unclear, they weren't really sure what they would be voting for or against. If you think you might not vote on referenda in your state because you don't know enough about them, leave a comment with your state and I will do some research for you. Here in California, the Secretary of State has a lovely website with the full text of each proposition, and perhaps more importantly, a pro and con section to show you who supports and who opposes each proposition and why. This was pivotal in clarifying that Proposition 5 is NOT a horrible tough on crime pile of crap, like it sort of sounds from the text. In fact, it's full of smart alternative sentencing options as briefly mentioned by Prof. Berman in his Sentencing blog.

Click here to see the rest of this post...

Tuesday, August 26, 2008

Round Here

I'm clearly at the end of my creativity as far as round up post titles is concerned.

Propaganda portraits, stopping propaganda, green travel wetnaps, online farmers market, NYT chocolate chip cookies, ogee, new to me DIY/craft site, Biden not so hot on crime and punishment issues.

So a few years back, when I subscribed to Vanity Fair, they had this big long article and photo spread about the then new wave of Russian fashion models. I had this vision of painting each photo like a Soviet propaganda poster. I did a bunch of research on Soviet posters and everything. Nothing came of it. Well the folks at Maopost had a similar idea but China and just regular people, maybe even you. Via Photojojo.

Speaking of propaganda, Nieman Watchdog has an excellent article on how reporters can stop inadvertently reinforcing misinformation.

OCD + Green. Biodegradable travel towels via Re-Nest.

An online farmers market in Maryland. Yes, Gentle Reader, I said Maryland. Via Re-Nest.

Not Martha did a comparison of Valhrona feves to Ghiradelli 60% Cacao chips in the New York Times chocolate chip cookie recipe. I didn't quite follow her pre-scooped experiment. Anyone care to interpret? For the ongoing saga of my adventures with this recipe, check here. And we eagerly await Rebecca's first batch report!

My word of the week: ogee. For a definition and fabric examples, please see True Up.

What's that phenomenon when you've never heard of something and then all of a sudden it's everywhere you turn? I'm experiencing that presently with the website Threadbanger. Threadbanger describes itself as

a network for people who love to DIY, recreate, refashion and craft. Forget about corporate stores, we’re here to help you create and find your own style! From our episodes, forum and blog to our newsletter and contests, there is something for everyone. Our goal is to bring together people who can share their ideas, tips and advice with others and help make the world more fashionable – Threadbanger style!
Should I like this site? Or is it just an attempt to be a cool version of Whip Up? Does craft have to try to be cool? Or is my real problem that I fear knit fabric and garment sewing so much that sites like Threadbanger just give me anxiety? I should really take an intro to knits class somewhere so I can just get over it.

My dreams of a revolutionary presidency in terms of law and order issues is somewhat tempered by the selection of Senator Biden as Senator Obama's running mate. For full details on my potentially dashed hopes, please see Prof. Berman's post.

Click here to see the rest of this post...

Monday, August 11, 2008

Green Maps & Prison

While flipping through Re-Nest the other day I came across a post about The Green Maps System. At first I thought, "I hope this has my town on it, because I have the need for green." Then I read this,

These maps highlight a community or city’s sustainable resource such as farmer’s markets, gardens and wildlife, bike paths, healthy dining, recycling centers and green businesses. The maps even identify places to avoid such as toxic wastes sites, nuclear facilities, poor labor practices, and prisons!
Prisons?!? OK, I understand not everyone appreciates a good prison like I do, but do prisons really warrant being on this map?
The implication is that prisons aren't green. In fact, the Federal Bureau of Prisons and its employees have received numerous awards for building state of the art environmentally friendly facilities. Compared to the suburban sprawl of McMansions most freeworlders live in, prisons use space more efficiently than pretty much anywhere on earth. Collective locally sourced food production is again more environmentally friendly than most public institutions.
So I sent the following email to Green Maps.
Good morning,
I was wondering why Green Map includes prisons as places to avoid? Obviously none of us would like to be imprisoned. I'm just wondering what led you to add prisons and not, say, bankruptcy courts.
Thank you,
Sarah
And they replied.
hi - the prison/detention center is in the Landmarks section, which means they can be indicated to help people navigate maps that don't have many streets labled, rather than really saying they are places to avoid. I guess a courhouse would be indicated with Governmental Office,,,,many thanks Wendy
Wendy E. Brawer
Founding Director
Green Map System
So the misconception of prisons as not environmentally friendly lies with the poster at Re-Nest, not the folks at Green Map. Though the lack of sense of humor - you know, we'd all like to avoid being inmates or bankrupt, you got my humorous parallel, right - is clearly located at Green Maps.

Click here to see the rest of this post...

Wednesday, July 30, 2008

I'm Back . . . with a Roundup

Since Bob & Rebecca are off to the Great White North, my Not Not Martha post got six whole comments (OK, two of them were from me, but STILL), and my blogging mojo seems to be on the fritz, I thought I'd post another round up of links from my favorite blogs . . . this time with a little more context so you can make an informed decision whether to click or not to click.

In honor of Bob & Rebecca's road trip to the frozen tundra, Photojojo has posted it's Ultimate Guide to Road Trip Photography.

A fun followup to my Opting Out post at Re-Nest in which they suggest a way to track which periodicals are selling your information to junk mailers AND simultaneously amuse your letter carrier.

Bob & Rebecca have a basement in need of pimping. Might I suggest, again via Re-Nest, Retro Plate concrete polishing?

Contemplating a no-dig garden on top of the cement pad of our patio, again via Re-Nest, which also links to the how-to.

A roundup of green fabrics and fibers via, wait for it, that's right, Re-Nest.

I had been enamored of the fabric birds which grace the cover of Last Minute Patchwork + Quilted Gifts, but I am perhaps even more enamored of the birds on the mobile over at Spool. Thankfully, they provide a free .pdf pattern. Via Design*Sponge.

Glad to see Our Gentle Reader and Rebecca are both reading The Omnivore's Dilemma. It will change your life! Or at least your approach to food. Don't forget to follow up with In Defense of Food, or you'll either never buy food again and starve to death or drop out and try to live on a self-sustaining family farm, which would probably lead to the same end result. More about Slow Food at the New York Times.

In the same post Gentle Reader alludes to the next book on her reading list, The Prosecution of George W. Bush for Murder, which reminded me to tell y'all about the Democracy Now interview with its author Vincent Bugliosi, in which he displayed all the signs of a schizophrenic off his meds. "There’s a strong sound in my ear here, there’s a big rattling sound here. . . . There’s a lot of noise in my left ear, a constant rattle; if you can get rid of it, I’d appreciate it. And—well, it’s not stopping." You really have to listen to the whole interview to get the full vibe. I mean, if the Bush administration is trying to make this guy look crazy to help bury the book, making his earphones go funny was HIGHLY effective.

Completely bummed that I missed the free streaming of Joss Whedon's latest project and contemplating enslaving myself to iTunes again in order to download it.

Picture of adorable baby bunnies at Field Trips in Fiber.

Interesting discussion of same sex marriage among inmates in California over at The Citizens.

Prof. Berman posts a Federal Bureau of Prisons portion of the U.S. Sentencing Commission's symposium on alternative sentencing. I'm willing to bet that if Director Lappin wasn't feeling some pressure from the AG, his cost/benefit analysis of halfway houses would be different. Could be worse, the BOP director could be a political appointee.

I, lack of television notwithstanding, am SO excited for the fifth season of Project Runway! Any suggestions on which three designers will garner the most Fafarazzi points? So far I'm languishing in 769th place with only two points from Tim Gunn telling Kenley to carry on in episode 2. I might be doing better if I'd actually read any of their bios or, you know, could watch the show.

Oh, and don't forget Am I Really Going Through This? I couldn't pick just one post. Preston goes camping, judges Anchorage's Gay Pride Parade, and gets crabs, not necessarily in that order. Nor do said events have any causal relationship to one another.

Click here to see the rest of this post...

Saturday, June 14, 2008

Not Not Martha

I'm a big fan of the blog Not Martha. She frequently collects links to things she digs and that's her post. I have mixed feelings about that approach to blogging. So I'm going to try it and see what you think.

Sealable glass reusable containers blogged at Re-Nest.

Hilarious Hulk movie review. "This is dedication to a motif." - Bob

Small scale mobile chicken coop like the one described in Michael Pollan's Omnivore's Dilemma, but on a backyard scale via Re-Nest.

The prettiest post about Amy Ruppel's hand printed fabric on design*sponge.

Preston goes shopping.

Dadaist quilting philosophy genius at Spirit Cloth.

Another high in depriving liberty: 7.2 million under CJ control at Prof. Berman's Sentencing Law and Policy blog.

The Colorspire colour schemer via Sharon B's In a Minute Ago.

Vickie's new dye studio at Field Trips in Fiber. Dear Bob & Rebecca, please do this in your basement before my next visit. Love, Sarah

Click here to see the rest of this post...

Thursday, May 22, 2008

A Torture Memo to be Proud Of

OK, maybe "pride" isn't the right word. But certainly the DOJ OIG report revealing the bottom up assertion that torture by the CIA and Defense Department is both widespread and (quick shocked inhale) wrong, is the kind of whistle blowing memo one can stand behind.

I have no interest in standing behind John Yoo's torture memos. Standing aghast at, maybe, but not standing behind.

Friday, May 02, 2008

Obama on Criminal Justice

I have talked a lot about Clinton's tough on crime stance, but I don't know that I've given enough information about Obama's position. As a State Senator, Obama passed one of the country's first racial profiling laws and helped reform a broken death penalty system. According to his website these are his four main criminal justice goals:

1. End Racial Profiling

Obama will ban racial profiling by federal law enforcement agencies and provide federal incentives to state and local police departments to prohibit the practice.

2. Reduce Crime Recidivism by Providing Ex-Offender Support

Obama will provide job training, substance abuse and mental health counseling to ex-offenders, so that they are successfully re-integrated into society. Obama will also create a prison-to-work incentive program to improve ex-offender employment and job retention rates.

3. Eliminate Sentencing Disparities

Obama believes the disparity between sentencing crack and powder-based cocaine is wrong and should be completely eliminated.

4. Expand Use of Drug Courts

Obama will give first-time, non-violent offenders a chance to serve their sentence, where appropriate, in the type of drug rehabilitation programs that have proven to work better than a prison term in changing bad behavior.

And for some of that famous Obama rhetoric, I give you an excerpt from his remarks at Howard University's Convocation in Washington, D.C., on September 28, 2007.

As President, I will also work every day to ensure that this country has a criminal justice system that inspires trust and confidence in every American, regardless of age, or race, or background. There's no reason that every single person accused of a crime shouldn't have a qualified public attorney to defend them. We'll recruit more public defenders to the profession by forgiving college and law school loans - and I will ask some of the brilliant minds here at Howard to take advantage of that offer. There's also no reason we can't pass a racial profiling law like I did in Illinois, or encourage states to reform the death penalty so that innocent people do not end up on death row.

When I'm President, we will no longer accept the false choice between being tough on crime and vigilant in our pursuit of justice. Dr. King said it's not either-or, it's both-and. We can have a crime policy that's both tough and smart. If you're convicted of a crime involving drugs, of course you should be punished. But let's not make the punishment for crack cocaine that much more severe than the punishment for powder cocaine when the real difference between the two is the skin color of the people using them. Judges think that's wrong. Republicans think that's wrong. Democrats think that's wrong, and yet it's been approved by Republican and Democratic Presidents because no one has been willing to brave the politics and make it right. That will end when I am President.

I think it's time we also took a hard look at the wisdom of locking up some first-time, non-violent drug users for decades. Someone once said that "...long minimum sentences for first-time users may not be the best way to occupy jail space and/or heal people from their disease." That someone was George W. Bush - six years ago. I don't say this very often, but I agree with the President. The difference is, he hasn't done anything about it. When I'm President, I will. We will review these sentences to see where we can be smarter on crime and reduce the blind and counterproductive warehousing of non-violent offenders. And we will give first-time, non-violent drug offenders a chance to serve their sentence, where appropriate, in the type of drug rehabilitation programs that have proven to work better than a prison term in changing bad behavior. So let's reform this system. Let's do what's smart. Let's do what's just.

Clinton is Tough on Crime . . . Which is Not Good

In these last few days before the Indiana primary, if you still think Hillary Clinton is the correct person to lead this country, please read Prof. Berman's post and the items to which he links.
To sum up: Rising imprisonment is the price the Clinton wing of the Democratic party is always eager to pay to win power. Rich, white, elected Democratic officials do not pay any direct price from rising imprisonment; the real costs of rising imprisonment are borne mostly by poor and minority populations and their families. Being the toughest with imprisonment terms, especially in the context of non-violent crimes, is not the only way for Democrats to win political power. Nevertheless, as Senator Hillary Clinton's expressed opposition to crack retroactivity highlights, the Clintonian eagerness to sell out poor and minority populations and their families through criminal justice politicking is not likely to change anytime soon.

When one in every one hundred adults is imprisoned, it is not only those inmates who lose. Our families lose. Our communities lose. Our country loses. We lose the right to call ourselves the home of the free. The Statue of Liberty no longer cries to the rest of the world to "Give me your tired, your poor, Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free." We can no longer declare "that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness."

Hope. Vote.

Wednesday, April 23, 2008

At least 3 people care about prisons

This is for Sarah, who is one of the above 3. Some interesting posts in the comments (if you ignore mine), but no direct discussion of _why_ prison reform is a political third rail.

I suppose indirectly there's some evidence however: many people say our massive imprisonment gets results, and the fact that the rest of the world isn't as unique as us explains why we need to imprison 1 out of every hundred adults. So what's to reform?

Yikes: "The United States has less than 5 percent of the world’s population. But it has almost a quarter of the world’s prisoners." Needless to say, we lead the world in imprisonment. This seems like a serious problem, especially when you consider Tyler Cowen's point that our prisoners face unusually dire circumstances by developed world standards.

 blog it

Thursday, January 31, 2008

Death in Georgia

The New Yorker has an excellent article about the prosecution of Brian Nichols for the 2005 courthouse shooting spree in Atlanta. It focuses on the challenges of defending the indigent. One of the main characters is Stephen B. Bright, the senior counsel for the Southern Center for Human Rights.

He is my hero. I saw him on a panel at the New School's conference on punishment in the U.S. Everyone was complaining about the piling on of post-release punishments for sex offenders when someone said something like, "The problem is, who is going to take on the incredibly unpopular role of the defender of sex offenders' rights." Bright raised his hand, "I am."

Monday, January 28, 2008

Prisons and Politics

If you asked me in 1988 who I would vote for in the Democratic primary in 2008 (because I knew in 1988 that I would be voting in the Democratic primary in 2008, don't all 14 year olds strongly identify with a political party?) and you told me my options, I would probably have voted for Hillary Clinton.

But then I went to law school and learned about the criminal justice system and now I cannot possibly vote for someone who opposes crack guideline retroactivity and who justifies this irrational position by citing Giuliani's apparently similar position. For those not in the sentencing know, back in the heyday of crack paranoia, the U.S. Sentencing Commission established sentencing guidelines which punished offenses related to crack 100 times longer than offenses related to powder cocaine. This has long been held up as an example of institutionalized racism in sentencing. Whether the U.S.S.C. was being racist or whether it was succumbing to the media frenzy, the result was bad law. The U.S.S.C. recently issued new guidelines which reduce this 100:1 disparity and recommended that they apply retroactively.

Clinton and the Bush Administration oppose the effort to make this change retroactive. This is the first evidence I've seen that Hillary is taking the same "tough on crime"/ irrational sentencing stance as her husband. While Bill Clinton was great for this country in many ways, he undermined the rights of the accused arguably more than any president in history. I expected better from Hillary. I am now officially disappointed. Therefore, I am not going to vote for Hillary Clinton.

Criminal justice reform is the new civil rights movement. And the Clintons are moving in the wrong direction.

Edit: It has recently been brought to my attention that in all fairness I should post all of the candidates' positions on retroactivity. Obama and Edwards support retroactivity. Clinton and Giuliani oppose retroactivity. I can't find Romney's or McCain's positions, though given Romney's attempts to be tough on crime in Massachusetts, I'd bet he's opposed. I emailed both of their campaigns to ask what their position on crack retroactivity is. I'll update if I hear anything.

Edit 2/12/2008: No, I haven't heard back from McCain, and I don't think Romney is taking this time off the campaign trail to respond to emails. But I did find another post over at Prof. Berman's blog that covers the candidates' positions on crime and punishment a little more thoroughly:"Where candidates stand on crime, death penalty".

Edit 3/25/2008: Still haven't heard back from McCain. But the ever wonderful Prof. Berman posted a link to The Sentencing Project's guide to the 2008 Presidential Candidates' Platforms on Criminal Justice that provides information on a range of key criminal justice issues, including sentencing policy, reentry, death penalty, and felony disenfranchisement.

Friday, June 29, 2007

Silverdocs: Hard Road Home

Hard Road Home
http://64.13.231.35/festival/films/hard-road-home/
http://www.hardroadhome.org/
Later on Friday I went to Hard Road Home, the third in my self-selected, uninterrupted prison film series, and the fourth of my Silverdocs 2007 adventure. While waiting outside to finish a soda perusing the Now Showing posters, I witnessed a harrowing scene. At first I thought it was a post-one-night-stand drama unfolding on the sidewalk. I heard a woman say, “I feel like I’ll never see you again, but I want you to take this anyway.” Then I saw the woman trying to force her business card on what I can only assume was a filmmaker as he gruffly tried to lose her by walking as fast as he could. Having witnessed a similar post-screening frenzy after Miss Gulag, I have come to the conclusion that one should not attempt to foist one’s business card upon a filmmaker at a festival unless you’re offering a distribution deal for this film or a grant for the next film. Has someone already coined the phrase “90 minute stand”?
In line for the film there were, perhaps not shockingly, more African-Americans in attendance than at any of the previous screenings I’d attended. I also noticed more Asian-Americans, a broader range of ages, and more male fashion victims than at previous screenings. In front of me in line a double date shared hot dogs from the concessions. The enormous cup holders in Theater 3 beg to filled. The director sits on the stairs and complains that the muzak playing before his film is too loud and inappropriate. It is ghastly. But is being a diva really the answer?

The film opens with audio of sirens over the visual of a city street. Griffik tells the camera what he did that landed him in prison. He was released three months ago. Though he speaks English, his words are subtitled.I have no idea what this means, but in my notes I wrote, “Hip Hop to Exodus.” Whatever it means, I love it. It might mean the audio is load hip hop music as the visual is the exterior of Exodus, the organization which is the subject of this film. But that sort of ruins the poetry, doesn’t it.Anyway, Julio, the head of Exodus, says their goal is to make sure no one goes back to prison. Exodus is run by former inmates. We know what it takes to succeed. Hip hop music plays over the title sequence.We might not be in “society” - not in prison, not Exodus staff member’s son in prison, on drugs, not dead.Griffik talks to one of the staff at Exodus. He does not have his parole officer’s telephone number. The staff member tells him he needs to keep that with him at all times. He wrote his parole officer’s telephone number on his birth certificate.During a group session with others recently released from prison, another young man like Griffik expresses his resistance to fitting into society. He blames oppressive cops and racism.A former inmate says, “I voted last year for the first time. I’m a free man.”Griffik tries to get a job. He says, “If you allow me to manipulate you, that’s your fault.”Julio worries about funding because they’re in the last year of a federal contract.When a parole officer tells a former inmate they have to do something, like attend anger management classes, or stay home after 9:00 p.m., they use the word “mandated.” Like “My P.O. mandated me to anger management classes.”Julio says people are redemptive.The films shows Julio (or is it the Exodus staff member who looks like Julio, Alberto?) having car trouble and marriage trouble. Alberto has been missing for four days. He is off the wagon. He left his family. The pacing seems slow because between various segments lots of long shots of the city are edited in, possibly showing the geographic transition from one segment to another. The filmmakers is showing the transitions in a film about transitions. Julio says to Griffik, “These cameras are going to stop rolling and that’s when your movie really begins.” Cut to black.

Q & A with the director and Julio

The film is going to be shown on PBS’s Independent Lens next year. The film is tied to two grassroots policy campaigns. On is a public/private partnership dedicated to implementing re-entry best practices. Another is a faith-based group Auburn Media.The contract Exodus was losing that led to their financial concerns was a federal faith-based contract that ended last August. You can make a donation at http://www.etcny.org/home.html . To measure success Exodus uses six life area benchmarks. The overall goal is reducing recidivism. Alberto plead guilty and was sentenced to 12 years to life for burglary.Exodus staff built trust before the cameras arrived. The cameras were there for a year so we wanted to show real challenges. It takes the entire staff to make a change in one person’s life.Griffik is working and in school.Many current staff members came through the Exodus program for their re-entry prior to working there. There is no time limit. Their doors are always open.A person in the audience asked whether Exodus went into prisons to begin pre-release programming with inmates six months prior to their release. Julio responded that New York state is challenging and Exodus doesn’t have the resources.The director explained that he selected the topic because he was looking for personal stories to illustrate the issue of transition. He learned about Julio as in individual success story and the challenges of re-entry faced by newly released inmates. Julio and the staff at Exodus were also so different from the burned out, unimpassioned government caseworkers who cannot identify with their clients because a prerequisite of working for the government is that you haven’t done prison time. His goal with the film was to galvanize viewers to promote better policy and to lift up the humanity of this population.

Thursday, June 28, 2007

Silverdocs: Hothouse

Hothouse

http://64.13.231.35/festival/films/hothouse/http://www.frif.com/new2006/hot.htmlOn

Friday I left work early to go to the early screening of Hothouse. I was second in the ticketholders line (as opposed to the passholders line who get to budge in front of us ticketholders). I chatted amiably with #1 and #3. #3 was a nineteen year old man. #1 was a woman with a nineteen year old son. This was discovered when #3 says his favorite film is The Sandlot, which is #1's son’s favorite film. I have never seen The Sandlot (http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0108037/). We bonded as three local film buffs sneaking out of work to enjoy the festival. We contemplated taking three days off of work next year to take it all in properly. #1 didn’t know what Hothouse was about. She just bought tickets for everything she could squeeze into her schedule. #1 and I recommended Cinema Paradiso (http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0095765/) to #3. He recommended Clap Your Hands Say Yeah (http://www.clapyourhandssayyeah.com/news.php) to us. Bonding with #1 and #3 reinvigorated my belief in film after it was decimated by the filmmakers’ vapid Q & A after Miss Gulag. Then there were very few passholders to budge in front of us and I found my favorite seat in Theater 1. I was half expecting cartoon birds and squirrels to bring me popcorn and a soda until I was surrounded by women complaining about their hotel rooms and manicures and the party a the Moose Lodge last night and not being able to find a taxi in Silver Spring and why do they have this festival in this god forsaken place . . . and if that’s not bad enough Harry Chapin’s Cat’s Cradle plays over the P.A. I wish my dad was here.

The film opens in February 2006 with a speech by the speaker of the new Palestinian parliament who mentions the members of the council who are in prison. He pledges to free all Palestinians in Israeli prisons. Fourteen members of parliament are in prison. Guard dogs bark at the camera as they run between two rows of fence around a prison.Intertitle: One year earlier.Be’ler Sheva PrisonInmates introduce themselves and state what crimes they were convicted of. Some say they are members of Hamas. For example, one says he sent suicide bombers to two locations. The prison looks modern and clean. Cells contain multiple bunk beds. At least four sets of bunks are visible. As one inmate begins to introduce himself while sitting on the lower bunk in his cell one of the other inmates tells him to speak in Arabic. He starts over again, speaking in Arabic rather than Hebrew. Many of the inmates who introduce themselves say they are from one or another refugee camp. Some say they were arrested for failing to liberate their land. Some cells are full of Hamas inmates. Other cells are full of Fatah inmates. But all of them are Palestinians. The windows of the prison are frosted so they cannot see outside. They joke that all they would see is desert, so why frost them? There is a television in each cell. They get Israeli and Palestinian channels. One says he didn’t think about politics on the outside because he was busy following orders. An off-camera interviewer speaks to Colonel Ofer Lefler, an Israeli prison spokesperson. He says there are 10,000 prisoners. The prison administration used to have a difficult time maintaining order among the Palestinian inmates. Then they decided to work with the leaders of the various Palestinian groups, such as Hamas and Fatah, and they helped to maintain order among the Palestinian inmates. There is a horrible electrical beep when sallyports open. The Fatah prisoners’ representative negotiates with a prison administrator, Warden Eshel, about privileges. When a correctional officer enters a cell the inmates stand by their beds. Inmates say they have political power because they get their families to vote for who they recommend. Inmates focus on politics and the news. The warden says they see Palestinian culture differently in prison. They have military discipline and a hierarchy. Each cell block has a representative. There will be no peace so long as the issue of prisoners remains. Buses passing through a bus sallyport.Hasan Yusuf is a Hamas candidate who was arrested. Israeli security services are trying to prevent a Hamas victory in the elections. Inmates exercise in a courtyard.An inmate performs the call to prayer from his cell. Inmates from around the cell blocks pray. Hasan Yusuf leads his cellmates in prayer.A newspaper shows pictures of all of the candidates from Ramallah. An inmate points out which were arrested. They were all in prison at one time or another. Many of the prisoners have academic degrees, especially in political science. Two inmates write answers to a political science exam while a correctional officer watches. Inmates state their names, degrees, and the school where they got the degrees. One of them got a graduate degree in biomedical engineering from Emory University. They say they are prohibited from studying Arabic. They learn Hebrew to talk to guards and prison doctors. They can get degrees from Hebrew University. An off-camera interviewer speaks with a failed suicide bomber. He says he wants to blow himself up to kill Jews. He is studying to do that when he is released.A man outside of prison says that prison taught him to use his time wisely. Now he gets respect from others because he was in prison for eight years.Hashfaron PrisonThis is a women’s prison. Some inmates wear burka. An inmate says female inmates have become Palestinian leaders. They have turned the jail into a school. They meet women from all over Palestine in prison. They read more. They know more about politics. Then the inmate says she is in prison for asking a friend to do a suicide bombing. Another female inmate says she planned the Sbarro suicide bombing and another suicide bombing. She said her arrest communicated the agenda of jihad. Another woman does not want to be filmed. A guard conducts bar taps in the women’s cells. A prison official says they are in a daily intelligence war within the prison. Inmates direct operations on the outside. A special operations response team conducts a drill. A prison official says coded notes that order attacks on the outside are referred to as “launchers.” A candidate in prison speaks at a political rally on the outside via cellphone over loudspeakers. Cellphones in prison are a huge problem. They are illegal. Intertitle: Ramalla one month before election.Prisons provide the best opportunity to create political activists. They are not allowed to organize outside. In Gaza prisoners who are released became political leaders. Prisoners in different prisons communicate with one another via attorneys and families. Every cell has an account book for each prisoner which records the amount of money and good each inmate has. These are all kept by the prison treasurer. The warden discusses issues with inmate representatives. They have a dialog regarding daily life in prison, for example building a new visiting facility. There are two different classifications, “Security Prisoners” and “Jewish Inmates.” The prison dentist tries to calm frustrated visitors. Each inmate has 45 minutes for visits. There is a digital red countdown clock, like a bomb, in the visiting room. Small children and babies are passed from the visitor to a guard and then to the inmate. A visitor says she refuses to be filmed. She asks the filmmaker, “Are you filming to solve our problem? If you’re just filming for sympathy, no.”An off-camera interviewer asks a female inmate about the children who were killed in the suicide bombing she was involved with. The inmate turns as if talking to another person and asks how is she to respond to that question when she has children of her own. A woman off-screen responds that she should say something about jihad. The camera pans to show the Sbarro bombing planner, smiling at the camera. Clearly she had just told the woman how to respond but when the camera is turned toward her, she appears to have said nothing. This woman was news reporter at the time of the bombing. She reported on the bombings she organized. She says suicide bombings are realizing the bomber’s dream. We don’t feel remorse. We are defending ourselves. If we get rights, we don’t want violence.A man on a donkey says he is going to vote.Intertitle: Ramalla on election dayPrisons prepared Palestinians for democracy because they conducted elections in prison for years and after the voting, they still had to live together. They meet to discuss peace during the voting. Various news outlets begin to report the election results. Fatah prematurely celebrates victory. Time lapse sunrise at the prison tower.Hamas wins majority. The prison leaders of both parties tell their followers to stay calm and act normally. The Fatah cell discusses why they lost. What kind of representatives are we in prison? A prison official says the inmates get to know Israelis not through gunsights. Prison disciplines and trains you. They get the tools to confront oppression.Quick cutting roll call of inmates stating their sentences in ascending order. Fade to black though prison bars. Credits over image of road.

Q & A with the film’s director

Q: Why didn’t you show lives of average Palestinians compared to the prisoners? There was no context.

A: Film is an exercise in limitation. I had curiosity about prison and the difference between the way Palestinian prisoners were portrayed and the way they see themselves. I deliberately tried to keep the film inside prison. At other screenings people have asked why have I not shown the victims of these people’s crimes. The answer is the same. There is limited time and scope.

Q: How did you get access? Did the Israeli Prison Services or Israeli Security Services review your footage?

A: The amount of access I eventually got was surprising. I asked. They said no. Again. No. Friends of mine in the administration said no, but let me see what I can do. Maybe one afternoon. You already got in once? OK, you can come in again. The prison authorities wanted to look good. There were no restrictions once I got in. A spokesperson asked to see the final cut before it was screened, but then he didn’t have time. It’s a grey world.

Q: How did you get access to the different Palestinian factions?

A: Working with the inmates was a process that took place over a year. I got to know them. It became a dialog. They knew I wasn’t in there to get a scoop or a soundbite. The factions are aware of the power of the camera. They used me as I used them. They educate eachother. They have safety in prisons other Palestinians don’t have. The film touches on something that needs to be studied further.

Q: [Something about prison politics versus outside politics]

A: Nothing is permanent. The relationships in prison are friendly. Prison administrators allow Palestinian inmates to congregate based on political affiliation. Productive for them and contal to negotiate with authorities. In response to present crisis, prison authorities separated Fatah and Hamas inmates for the first time.

Q: How was the film received in Israel and Palestine?

A: In Israel it was shown on national television. El Arabiya showed it in three episodes with a panel discussion following each one. In Gaza people saw their family members they had not seen for years. Some in Israel don’t want to give the inmates a voice. They appreciated what I had done and the thought that went into it and that people should listen.