Showing posts with label math. Show all posts
Showing posts with label math. Show all posts

Sunday, November 01, 2026

What? Well, I've been using Evernote to write down thoughts, but they're just to myself, and sometimes I want someone else to read them. You, specifically. I want you to read them.

There's a Youtube video of a podcast called "The Rest is Science" with Vsauce (the curiosity box guy) and Hannah Fry (the British everything to do with maths woman), called " Why Is It A Colour Wheel And Not A Line?" Here, I can probably make a link to it, right?

And it's interesting, but I think they sort of get to the "magenta isn't really a color" conclusion,and think I can describe the phenomenon in a way that is less glib and more enlightening. So I offer this thought: color is like music. Specifically, like hearing different notes. You want to read more, right?

Hm. This is where there's supposed to be a "click to read more...", and it's not working. I can't imagine Blogger has changed anything in the years since my last post...

Anyhoo...

Think about hearing an instrument play a note. What note it is is a musical way to describe its frequency: if the sound we hear is at 440Hz, it's an "A", higher notes are higher frequencies, lower notes are lower frequencies. So far, this is exactly like frequencies of light: we perceive red, a higher frequency is yellow, higher is green, etc. This is the "colo(u)r should be on a line" view.

But the sound of a trumpet playing an A, and a harmonica playing an A, and a piano playing an A, and a guitar playing an A, are all the same frequency but unquestionably different and we perceive those differences clearly -- if I asked you which was which just from the sound, you could do so with confidence. Why? Because your ear gets more information than just what the dominant frequency of a sound is. Your eardrum reacts on a complicated way to the air pressure changes hitting it, capturing lots of information for your neurons to process.

Separately, we can synthetically extract information out of an audio signal with a Fourier Transform, which lets us break a signal into component frequencies that represent the sound if it were decomposed into sine waves. This isn't exactly what your ear is doing, but we can observe with Fourier Transform that these different instruments have their own characteristics of which overtones (frequencies larger than the primary one that identifies the note) appear in the Fourier Transform, with what intensity profile. This "explains" how we can perceive the timbre of an instrument - we don't just hear one frequency, we hear the overtones too. The sound is more than just one sine wave at one frequency, we hear more of the complexity of the actual sound, and we recognize different instruments even though they play the same note. This sentence may seem a little obvious, so just remember that I put it in bold for some reason and keep reading.

A key part of music is playing different notes at the same time: careful constructions of several notes at the same times are chords, and they're what harmony is all about. The three notes of a major chord seem to blend together and produce a sound that seems other than the sum of its parts, even though that's really what it is. Our ear captures some of the complexity of the multi-note sound, and our brain registers it as its own thing, not "just" a mix of three notes, but as some special mix of those three notes. I think almost nobody thinks this is weird, or that our brain is tricking us into hearing something that isn't there. We can describe some interesting frequency relationships between the chords that sound nice and the collections of notes that sound like they have nothing to do with each other, so we shouldn't be surprised that our ear can pick up on that.

Getting back to color, I think the misstep is thinking "color" means "a frequency of light", when our eyes are taking in different information than that. We've got three types of color receptor "cones" in our eyes, which are collecting intensity measures centered on three different frequencies, red, green, and blue. So not unlike the color system for computer graphics, your eye is collecting, not a single frequency, not an average frequency, but three different values, like "this is very blue and a little green and a little less red" or more accurately, "the cones that trigger hard on a blue frequency are triggering hard, the cones that trigger hard on green are triggering a little, and the cones that trigger hard on red are triggering a little less than that."

If the information coming in is the same as we'd get from a single frequency of light, then we perceive that single frequency of light, just like if I play a sine wave, I hear that the note produced by that one frequency. But if the information is coming in is an interesting combination of the cone responses -- lots of red-triggering and blue-triggering, but not green-triggering, for example (but see below), then this is like a musical chord: the light is more than just one sine wave at one frequency, and we see more of the complexity of the actual light. It's not that magenta isn't real, it's that what we see as "color" isn't limited to what's on the linear spectrum of single frequencies, just like we aren't limited to just hearing single frequencies.

And I want to point out that there's no reason to assume that magenta is the only color that isn't on the spectrum - it's just the easiest to describe.

First, let me outline what happens when we see a single frequency of light. There's an orange-yellow, for example, with a frequency f that produces the same response from the red-cones and green-cones. It also produces a response in the blue-cones, but it's much lower. Suppose the intensity of light is such that the red-cones and green-cones is X. Then the blue-cone response Z is perfectly determined from the intensity and the blue-cone response curve to frequency f. In other words, every time we see a pure light of frequency f, with this given intensity, the information the eye sends to the brain will be red-cones X, green-cones X, blue-cones Z.

So every signal of red-cones X, green-cones X, blue-cones (anything but Z) describes a color that is not on the spectrum of single frequencies. This doesn't mean it's made up, or that our brain generates an illusory color: it means that we perceive something more complex than a single frequency, and our brains process that as a color that isn't equivalent to a single frequency, because it's smarter than that.

Color isn't "a frequency of light", but each single frequency of light has a color. It's just that combinations of multiple frequencies have their own color too, and we can tell the difference, just as we can tell the difference between a guitar and a piano, even if the primary frequency they're playing is the same.

I will just conclude by noting that we have analysis (splitting things into parts) going on, like recognizing that white light is made up of a bunch of different frequencies, and that each note is primarily a single frequency, along with synthesis - our ear or eye capturing more than one frequency and our brain putting the multifrequency information it gets into a perception different from the single frequency case.

Click here to see the rest of this post...

Wednesday, May 27, 2020

Change to my Tweets about coronavirus data

It's frustrating to do this, but it has to be done. I'm going to change the thing I've been reporting. And (possibly worse), I'm going to tell you why. (Basically, I'm fixing something I should've been doing all along.)

  I've been trying to report a measurement to try to communicate how fast the rate of infection was, how the rate was different in different places, and how it was changing (thankfully, slowing down) over time. This has always involved some inference: the new cases each day aren't the same as the total new infections, just the ones that were being diagnosed; similarly, the total cases aren't the same as the total infections in the community, just the ones that were being treated. The assumption is that, roughly speaking, the new cases was some (relatively constant) percentage of the new infections, and the total cases was some (relatively constant) percentage of the total infections. 

 Early on, "total cases" seemed as good a measure as any to substitute for the total number of people infected. But for a while now, there's been both good and bad news. People don't stay infected, as "active cases". Many get better. Sadly, some die. All of them, hopefully, once they become "active cases", are isolated and are much less likely to infect someone else. The "total cases", which I've been using, counts all the people in the state/region/etc. who have been diagnosed with the virus. It includes the recovered and the dead, as well as the cases still being treated. 

 Early on, there wasn't much difference between active cases and total cases. Now, in New York, there are over 279,000 active cases, which is a LOT. There are over 29,000 deaths, which is TOO MANY. And there are over 64,000 people who have recovered, which is a GREAT START. And I'm trying to figure out which number is the best representative of the number of infected people in the population. 

It doesn't have to be closest to that number, it needs to correlate with it: if there's twice as many infected people out there right now, you'd expect twice as many... 
active cases. 

 So I'm going to start reporting areas based on the threshold of new cases over the last 7 days being higher or lower than 10% (or 5%) of the _active cases_, not _total cases_. This will momentarily mean more areas will be above each threshold. But I think it's more accurate, and over time, the trend will tell us more about how fast (or slow) the disease is spreading. 

 As was always the case, this can do weird things for areas where the numbers are smaller generally, especially if the reporting of active cases is peculiar (Vermont, for example, lists 967 total cases, but only 65 active cases; I don't know if they've had 850 or so recoveries, or if those people have been moved to other states, or what. I have no reason to question these figures, but it could be Vermont's really good recovery rate is temporarily making them look like they have a faster spread rate).

 Another thing that should eventually put a hitch in my numbers is testing. As testing gets more and more widespread, the number of new cases should go up, as more infected people are found and treated. But that's a good thing! So if a state jumps back into the >10% category when they're testing more broadly, that isn't a reason for alarm - it's the longer term trend after the jump that really matters. 

 Okay, without further ado...as of today (I'm sorry, I'm going to have to report the new numbers going forward, and haven't recalculated the data for the past), here’s the parts of the US that had a daily increase in COVID cases >10% of their current active cases: ID,MN,Veteran Affairs,WV. >5%: AL,AK,AR,KY,MS,NV,SC,SD,TX,US Military,VT (the rest were less).

Click here to see the rest of this post...

Wednesday, July 25, 2018

A different justification for the Schulze Method

This is a different way to think about the Schulze Method, which might convince people who don't like the "beatpath" construction. 

I wrote about the Schulze method in the previous post, giving a justification that is based on the standard presentation of the method using beatpaths.


This is a different look at the same method, implemented a different way.

Suppose you first looked for a Condorcet winner: so you look at all the pairwise matchups, and find out who is preferred to who.  You make a matrix of pairwise preferences, and maybe for convenience subtract the number of voters who preferred Y to X from the number who preferred X to Y to get the margin of pairwise preferences.  (These matrices are in the example in the Wikipedia link to the Schulze method above -- if I were more detail-oriented, I'd put an example here.) 

Any row that's all positive means that candidate beats all others head-to-head: that's a Condorcet winner!  

But suppose there isn't a row that's all positive.  What do we do?  Well, first, we can eliminate any Condorcet loser: a candidate that is not preferred in any head-to-head matchup. (We'll spot a Condorcet loser in the matrix because it's got a row of margins that's all negative, or equivalently a column that's all positive.)[see footnote]

Then, since we want the closest thing to a Condorcet winner, let's "grade on a curve", and do one of the following (these are equivalent):


  • add something to all the margins: add 5 (for example) to all the margins of pairwise preferences  (add more if you haven't changed anything from negative to zero/positive, add less if you've changed too many elements) OR
  • find the negative margin that's closest to zero (-3 is closer than -10) and set it to zero.
Is there a row with no negatives now?  If so, that's our winner.  If not, our curve might've produced a definite loser (with a column that's all positive or zero), so eliminate that candidate [see footnote again] and curve some more, either adding more or zeroing out another negative margin, until you've got a row with no negatives.  It isn't a Condorcet winner, but it's the next best thing -- the candidate that started with the smallest pairwise "unpreferences".

[ Here's the footnote: ] technically, you want to eliminate every candidate not in the "Schwarz set", which is not just a Condorcet loser, but any group of candidates that loses to everyone outside the set.  (In other words, it doesn't matter if candidate D beats candidate E, if D and E both lose to A, B, and C, eliminate both of them - clearly the winner should be A, B, or C.)   But in terms of justification, this is a technical point; the idea is that you're looking for the "closest to Condorcet" winner.


Click here to see the rest of this post...

Voting Methods: Making the case for the Schulze Method

If you're curious about voting methods, and/or want to make a case for a Condorcet method to your friends and co-voters, this post is for you!  

First, I think the Condorcet criterion is pretty compelling on its own.  (The Condorcet criterion is: if there's one candidate that is preferred in head-to-head matchups to every other candidate, that candidate wins.)  It's easy to come up with examples where the plurality method (this is the method that gets applied most often - whoever gets the most votes wins, even if that isn't more than half the votes -- boo plurality!) doesn't give you what seems the right solution.  If there is a Condorcet winner (there isn't always), it's the one that seems like the right answer.

So what if there isn't a Condorcet winner?  What voting method do you pick?  This is a case for the Schulze method: if there isn't a Condorcet winner, that's because there's a "rock-paper-scissors" cycle where candidate A is preferred (head-to-head) to candidate B, B is preferred to C, ... , Y is preferred to X, and X is preferred to A.  (The cycle can be size 3, like rock-paper-scissors, or can be longer - the point is it circles back on itself.)

At first glance, a cycle like that seems intractable - how do we rank any of the candidates in the cycle higher than the other?  But this is ignoring the strength of the preference:

Suppose 90% of voters prefer Rock to Scissors, 85% prefer Scissors to Paper, and 51% prefer Paper to Rock.  The cycle is there, but clearly the Paper > Rock preference is the weakest link.  The preference path Rock > Scissors > Paper has a "strength" of 85%, much higher than the 51% for Paper > Rock.  Based on path "strength", we can rank these Rock>Scissors>Paper.

Is Rock a Condorcet winner?  No.  But it's the closest thing to a Condorcet winner, in the sense that its pairwise loss is the weakest.

That's the Schulze method.  It's written in terms of "beat paths", but those are just breaking a cycle into two parts, like we did splitting "Rock>Scissors>Paper>Rock" into "Rock>Scissors>Paper" and "Paper>Rock" and comparing them.  There's some added detail to deal with multiple cycles between the same candidates, but that's really all there is to the idea of the method.

Next I hope to show another case to be made for the Schulze method, which might be more intuitive.


Click here to see the rest of this post...

Wednesday, August 18, 2010

Morning Expiration

See, I was inspired by something this morning, and so my comments in response are my expiration, get it? No one is dying, exhaling, or running out of time. (Any faster than normal, that is.)

Anyway, the inspiration was Stephen Fry's Podgram on Language. My expiration is about math.

Stephen (I call him Stephen, 'cause we're friends. On Twitter, but still) refers to language as intrinsic to humans. Those children purposely raised without exposure to any language went and invented their own. The capacity for language, and more, the capacity to express and enjoy the beauty of language, is inside you from the moment you're born. Also, he briefly laments how not very many enjoy language. "Words, it seems, belong to other people...The free and happy use of words appears to be considered elitist or pretentious." Those few who bother with language, Stephen asserts, "bother with it in quite the wrong way." He then mounts a tirade against the "pedants" who write letters to the editor complaining about grammar errors in the grocery, "in which they show off their own superior `knowledge' of how language should be".

Of course, while on the road to work, this reminded me of math. First, math is as innate, perhaps more intrinsic, than language. Math is physically innate: you are born with counting hardwired at the ends of your limbs -- your digits, naturally. I don't think it's too bold to say that the fundamentals of number and division, for example, are fundamentally ingrained in our minds, too. When we think kids have to "learn to count", really we mean that they need to learn we call the numbers (tying the math to the language), but the numberness of numbers is that "this many" of my fingers is the same as "that many" of sheep or rocks or other kids or what have you.

Second, if the deft use of language is derided, and enjoying language is elitist...then using math suffers doubly, triply, a thousand times moreso. I know of no society, no matter how anti-intellectual, in which it is socially acceptable to say "I'm illiterate". And if you're being picky, "illiterate" implies writing; the claim "I can't do English" is nearly unthinkable (and nearly self-contradicting). But "I can't do math" is as acceptable as commenting on the weather.

Third, I can't avoid wondering if there isn't a frighteningly stark parallel between the pedants Stephen detests so much and...well, are those few who bother with math showing off their superior `knowledge' of how math should be? Are we, also, bothering with it in quite the wrong way? There's a natural response about the "correctness" of math being critical to its mission -- a message can be communicated even with incorrect grammar, but math is too fragile to hold on to its meaning in the face of error. But still, that's math in the small...we overlook "arithmetic errors" in higher level math all the time. Is it really so impossible to focus on the "big picture" in algebra, geometry, arithmetic? Or are we pedants and sticklers as much by inclination and tradition as by necessity?

Click here to see the rest of this post...

Thursday, May 07, 2009

Innumeracy followup



It's remarkably annoying to try to count out 200 grains of anything. So I played it safe -- I counted out 50 grains, what I'd spilled was over twice that, so I threw two more sprinkles on top. So that's definitely over 200 grains, probably around 300.

In other words, one of those grains is in proportion to that pile at the same ratio as Obama's budget cut is to the budget. That pile, in proportion to the Gobi Desert, is how inaccurate Judd Gregg's statement was.

Mr. Gregg's my first casualty -- take notice, politicos. You bring up the sand, you're in MY HOUSE.

Tuesday, April 21, 2009

No learning, no responsibility

This is a quote from Ta-Nehisi Coates:


A kid may well blame himself for doing poor on a math test by saying he's stupid, but that doesn't mean he's taken responsibility, that he's acknowledged that he's capable of doing better the next time.

I bring this up because I thought it was insightful. It ties in well with one of the deep seated myths of math (and possibly other academic fields): "Either you can do math, or you can't." If you think about it, this simply denies the whole notion of learning. And if you assume you can't learn, that implies you're not capable of doing better. So, you're not responsible, right?

Tuesday, March 31, 2009

Shools need Shills

Casinos, and less reputable organizations (like marketers), regularly employ shills: people playing the game not for fun, but to keep the game going if there are too few players, and/or just to ramp up players' enthusiasm. One could get into a heavy discussion of whether a shill is actually "playing" the game at all (the term shill usually implies playing with house money, not keeping any winnings), whether the presence of shills implies a metagame around the original game, etc.

But my question is this: if shills are effective enough that casinos use them, why don't we use them in classes?

Consider the (unsubstantiated - send me references!) truisms:


  • a few good students can enhance the learning environment for everyone else;
  • peer regulation is the most effective enforcement of classroom discipline;
  • students ask questions in classes that other students are asking questions in;
  • students won't do what you tell them to, but will model themselves after peers that they see as successful.


Imagine you could plant a student who would ask the poignant question of the day, who would patiently help the struggling student while you addressed the rest of the class, and who would be your eyes and ears in the back of the room. Imagine a student who could ask probing but answerable questions of the strong students, credibly asking for help.

Sure, some of these tasks could be done with a TA, but a shill _models desired behavior_, and the only person better than a shill would be an actual role model student. And there's not enough of those for every class. Maybe because not enough students had a shill show them how to be.

I just told my differential equations class to read a section in the book and teach it to me next time. Which they took as a joke, but might actually make a decent exercise. But it got me to thinking -- what if they _always_ had someone to teach to, asking all the right questions?

Thursday, March 05, 2009

Shaking the Foundations of Mathematics

So, I was reading The Nothing That Is: A Natural History of Zero by Robert Kaplan this morning. It can be a bit pretentious (incessant quote-dropping, referring to his main concept "the Great Paradigm"), but it also has brilliant descriptions. Descriptions of historical developments in mathematics, but also descriptions of the properties of numbers that are so fundamental that one forgets how fascinating they are. For example, he points out the somewhat magical evolution of numbers from adjectives ("your four sheep and my eight sheep make a flock of twelve sheep") to nouns ("four and eight is twelve").

As a result, I was thinking that mathematics was born from the idea that you could abstract numbers from things. That is, four sheep and four sheep makes 8 sheep, AND 4 stones and 4 stones makes 8 stones, and so you can use stones to count your sheep and all the adding and subtracting and whatever works out fine.

(Sarah: Why on Earth were you thinking that?
Bob: Oh, contemplating the foundations of math and what it relates to comes with the territory. )

But we don't know that adding sheep and adding stones always works out. We just know that it almost always works out, and when it doesn't work out, usually it's because we lost a stone or a sheep or something, and eventually they turn up.
The only way the stones and sheep (and therefore, ALL numbers) wouldn't really match up is if the amount of things changed while we weren't looking. If sheep were flickering in and out of existence. Ridiculous!
...
But of course, we don't know where the sheep are when we're a sheep short, we just usually find them later. But sometimes, we lose stuff and it just seems to disappear. And sometimes we find it again, but somewhere we definitely checked before. So maybe this flickering in and out of existence does happen.

(Sarah: Oh, it TOTALLY does.
It is an especially common phenomenon among socks.
It is an especially common phenomenon within dryers.)

What's more, I am a big fan of Dad's observation that "There are things that are true, and things that are false, and also things whose truth value is not so fixed. In particular, there are statements that are true if you believe them." (Don't believe me? How about "I can't do math?" I'm not saying disbelieving it will make it false, but you can't simultaneously believe you're incapable of it and do it, regardless of what "it" is.)

So what if the sheep and stones and keys and socks would flicker MORE, except that we BELIEVE in mathematics?

(Sarah: That's entirely true. If you don't believe in socks getting lost in the dryer, they won't be lost in the dryer. But misplace one sock and BELIEVE it got lost in the dryer and you will never pull a matching pair of socks from your dryer again.)

If so, the extent of things flickering in and out of existence is, like an inverse Tinkerbell thing, derived from people's innumeracy, specifically their failure to believe in the consistency of numbers. After all, when we say "hmm...I've got two more stones here than sheep...oh well, there must be two more sheep out there I haven't seen", then we go look for the sheep. If we just said "Oh well, more stones than sheep", we may never see those sheep again. And they might not even BE anymore.

(Sarah: You must post this discussion to the blog. I mean what is a blog with an INNUMERACY tag if no one posts about innumeracy?
It would be as though innumeracy doesn't exist.
It went the way of the sheep for which there are stones.)

In conclusion:


  • First, it's a good thing we are teaching kids times tables and stuff, because if we weren't, we could lose whole people (Amelia Earhart), whole ships (in the Bermuda Triangle), whole cities (Atlantis)...OMG, maybe we have!

    (Sarah: We totally did.
    No one believed a woman could fly around the world . . . and Amelia Earhart ceased to exist.)
  • And Second, this is a dangerously self-fulfilling thing. All the wrong answers from all the students aren't wrong in the sense that there's an objective truth they're failing to fulfill, they're wrong because we desperately cling to what we need to be right.

(Sarah: I had this dream last night where the I said, "I live in a constant state of the contingency of if-ness."
I'm not making that up.
It's totally true.
And then you started this conversation.
And my dream came true.
God, I have to start having more interesting dreams.
Bob: That is wild. And doesn't "contingency" mean "if-ness"?
Sarah: Which is exactly what I thought when I woke up.
Like word for freakin' word.
Bob: We're uncanny. Like X-Men.
Sarah: LOL
If only we were self-regenerating and our bones covered in Adamantium also like X-Men.
Gotta run.
Bob: ttyl)

Click here to see the rest of this post...

Tuesday, February 24, 2009

Help me!

So, Mom sent me a clipping that includes this very interesting editorial about apparently little things with big impacts in education.

There's lots of intriguing stuff in there, but let me draw your focus to one alluring comment:


Black students also perform better on an exam when it is presented as a puzzle rather than as a test of academic achievement or ability, another study has shown.

Unlike most of the other cited research, this is all the detail Professor Nisbett gives about this.

Your task, should you aspire to SUPER COOLNESS: find me this study, or a citation of it, or really ANYTHING more about it. How do you present an exam as a puzzle? Did nonblack students perform better on puzzles than exams? What, in short, is he talking about here?

Richard Nisbett, the author of the editorial, has written lots of intriguing books, and has his own website, including a list of selected publications. I've looked over these, but none of them say something like "Narrowing the Achievement Gap through Assessment Restructuring", let alone "Puzzle Tests".

And thus, my first web puzzle, which I pose to you. Find me the puzzle exam study, and treasures will be yours. If you don't, the princess will be lost! Help!

Update: Waiting to hear back from Joshua Aronson, one of the "stereotype threat" researchers featured in the editorial (Nisbett forwarded my email to him.) Therefore, there is STILL TIME to submit your candidates for puzzle style examinations (Raven matrix tests seem possible) and other puzzle-based education studies. Find the research, save the world!

Update II: Aronson promptly and helpfully got back to me, with copies not only of the source for Nisbett's comment, but also another similar paper. And the results will SHOCK YOU! (Well, maybe.)

The referred paper is "The Difference Isn’t Black and White: Stereotype Threat and the Race Gap on Raven’s Advanced Progressive Matrices" by Ryan Brown and Eric Anthony Day, published in the Journal of Applied Psychology, 2006, Vol. 91, No. 4. The study contrasts, as Nisbett said, the way a test (in particular, "Raven's Advanced Progressive Matrices") is presented. When the participants were told it was an IQ test, African Americans underperformed whites. But when they were told it was a set of puzzles, and the researchers wanted the participants' opinions, African Americans performed just as well as whites. The test itself was unchanged.

The related paper is the seminal work on stereotype threat by Claude M. Steele and Joshua Aronson: "Stereotype Threat and the Intellectual Test Performance of African Americans", published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1995, Vol. 69, No. 5. This paper is the source for many of the other results in Nisbett's editorial, including the striking result that asking participants to specify their race on a form before administering a test created an achievement gap between blacks and whites; without the race question on the pre-test questionnaire, there was no achievement gap.

Here's some answers to questions that came up (from colleagues and myself) regarding these studies:


  • These were psychological studies; in a classroom setting, claiming a test is just a set of "puzzles" (that constitute part of the class grade) wouldn't have the same effect.
  • On the other hand, if I were to present students with "math puzzles" that begin as not counting for a grade, on which students achieve well, they will surely exhort me to count them (after the fact) for a grade. This would achieve the aim of assessment disguised as non-assessment, as well as students thinking I'm super-nice and giving me good evaluations.
  • "Raven's Advanced Progressive Matrices" are not nearly as exciting or puzzle-like as they sound. The appropriate Wikipedia page includes a link to a website that mimics these test questions; they are pattern-matching, nonverbal questions that might be familiar to you from IQ tests you may have taken in the past. Disappointingly for me, one can't present typical algebra content in this form.
  • White students performed better (though not very significantly) on tests described as measuring their ability, while black students performed better on tests that were described as puzzles or research not meant to assess their ability. (You can imagine the white students "slacking off" when there's no pressure to achieve.) However, black students' performance on "puzzles" was as good as white students' performance when the test was presented as measuring IQ (their best category.)
  • It seems to me the biggest take-home message is that we can, perhaps unwittingly, draw students' attention and promote their anxiety, which can have a big (negative) effect on their test performance.
  • As Rebecca pointed out, there is a vicious assessment cycle; the people writing tests are those who did well on prior tests, and thus see nothing wrong with the conventional test structure. Students that might be otherwise good at math, but who perform poorly on tests, suffer the consequences, and do not continue in math far enough to be in a position to write different tests for the next generation.

This does not mean the challenge is over, although the KNOWN sources have been found. I welcome ANY citations of research on the topics of puzzle tests and games, if such things exist. (And yes, you should feel free to write your own paper on the efficacy of "puzzle tests", then send me the citation and demand a gold star.)

Click here to see the rest of this post...

Thursday, February 19, 2009

Round Up

In this round up: Cap City compost bin discount, green home in the ATL, White House solar panels, pharm animals, studio organization, sheep to shawl, kangaroo rescue, K.C. Cole on math, non-hierarchical management, and high-yield produce is less nutritious.

Re-Nest has a very informative post about discounts on compost bins for Richmond, Virginia, residents. Well, OK, it's for all of central Virginia, but I know a few readers of this blog happen to live in Richmond, so I'm trying to appeal to them specifically. Did you catch that Bob and Rebecca? No pressure.

Jetson Green posted about a green home in Atlanta, Georgia. I wish it were mine. Via Re-Nest.

Re-Nest also has an informative post about the history of the solar panels on the roof of the White House.

David saw the cute goat pictures in the paper this morning and DEMANDED that I blog about Andrew Pollack's article F.D.A. Approves Drug From Gene-Altered Goats. Most importantly I am to direct you to the goat graphic.

Whip Up is posting a series about craft studio organization that is quite inspiring. I'm particularly enamored of the functional storage examples collected in this post. My studio will get there, gosh darn it!

I few weeks ago I heard a great report on NPR's Day to Day about a sheep to shawl competition. Definitely worth a listen.

Due the horrible fires in Australia apparently there is an spike in the number of orphaned baby kangaroos, a.k.a. joeys. Apparently these orphans need pouches. Whip Up has a nice post with a super cute picture of a joey in a pouch and a link to an organization collecting pouches.

I just heard a piece on Marketplace by K.C. Cole about the human brain's inability to comprehend large numbers. Apparently Ms. Cole has written a number of books on math and science for lay people. The mini-bio at the end of the Marketplace piece mentioned The Universe and the Teacup: The Mathematics of Truth and Beauty. At first I thought it might have to do with math and art, but from the descriptions on Amazon, not so much. Anyone read her books and feel like recommending one?

Rebecca has been sharing a lot of awesome stuff through Google Reader so I thought I'd pass them on. First, Kottke's post about non-hierarchical management in the workplace. Rebecca noted, "It'd be interesting to study this in the classroom too. I think that often it takes more than one, but certainly there can be an effect."

Seconding what I've posted about, Kottke posted about how high-yield produce has been found to be less nutritious. Rebecca noted, "I guess paying twice as much for organic vegetables is justified because I don't have to eat twice as many." Which is pretty much word for word what the Organic Consumers Association concluded.

Click here to see the rest of this post...

Thursday, December 11, 2008

Saturday, September 06, 2008

It's not politics, it's math!

No, really! Here, let me show you...wait, where are you going?...Come back!

Okay, for anyone who hasn't run screaming, here's the political/media intro. If you're like me, you've heard talking heads give one-sentence summaries of Obama's tax breaks for 95% of ....

finish that sentence. Then click the "...see the rest..." to see if we agree.


The pundits/reporters I've heard lately say "95% of the middle-class" (or middle-class families or middle-class taxpayers or whatever.)

This is in fact categorically false, if you think about it.

Obama's plan has tax breaks for "the 95 percent-plus of the American population that earns less than $250,000". That of course includes lower class incomes (no matter how you define that), and assuming you're not John McCain, all the middle class too.

Rebecca tells me that I just came upon a reporter parroting the Republican line about "95% of the middle class". Of course, this false characterization serves their purposes, since it engenders the question "what 5% of the middle class is Obama leaving out? Am I in that 5%?" when of course, if you really are middle class, you have nothing to worry about.

Click here to see the rest of this post...

Wednesday, June 11, 2008

Wednesday's with R.J.


For the past five weeks or so I have had a weekly lunch date with a fascinating woman I met at the Bloomington Quilt Guild named Rosemary Trubitt. She's an art quilter whose work is available at The Wandering Turtle Art Gallery. And she's a pretty amazing person to boot.

Here's Rosemary with some of her quilts. On the right you might be able to just make out a few of her mathematical quilts. Specifically they're equilateral spirals approximated using Fibonacci proportions. Prior to these Fibonacci spirals, she made a series of four different mathematical quilts inspired by Mathematical Quilts: No Sewing Required by Diana Venters and Elaine Krajenke Ellison. Her four quilts were then supplemented by five more quilts by BQG members and are now available in the Monroe County School District for teachers to use.

Click here to see the rest of this post...

Wednesday, May 28, 2008

Innumeracy Watch: post #B

So, I'm stepping through a Flash-driven online course on computer security that I'm required to take so that I can learn how to be a HUMAN FIREWALL (always capitalized, apparently), and I learn that "RISK = Vulnerability x Threat x Asset Value". Of course, those terms on the right hand side are carefully defined for me.

Only one of them is actually a NUMBER.

Tuesday, April 08, 2008

Bob's Innumeracy watch

Apologies to Ms. Beard for posting the whole article, but hey, if your math wasn't deceptive I wouldn't be forced to do this.
clipped from www.azcentral.com


Betty Beard
The Arizona Republic
Apr. 6, 2008 09:05 PM


The recent rise in Phoenix's housing prices means that in some cases the cost of owning a house grew too high compared with the cost of renting one, says a new report from the Center for Economic and Policy Research, in Washington, D.C.


Based on 2006 housing costs, the cost of renting in the Phoenix area averages $862 while the average cost of owning can range from $1,343 to $1,804, depending on interest rates, the report said. That means that Phoenix rental costs can range from 47 to 64 percent of ownership costs.

The report says that when ownership costs exceed 50 percent, it indicates a bubble. Some "extraordinary" gaps include New York City, where it costs 109 percent more to own a home than to rent; San Diego, 133 percent; San Francisco, 161 percent; and Los Angeles, 168 percent.
 blog it


The percentages cited for other cities use a middle-cost scenario, while the Phoenix range of costs for owning is the low-cost and high-cost scenarios. So even if you knew better, you'd need to read the article to find the apples-to-apples comparison, which is this: the cost of ownership in Phoenix exceeds the cost of renting by 78%.

That's what those percentages mean, by the way: the article drops some critical words -- it should be "...when ownership costs exceed rental costs by 50 percent or more, it indicates a bubble."

Oh, and that "47 to 64 percent"? That's dividing the cost of renting by the (low and high scenario) cost of owning, which isn't directly comparable to any of the other results. Also, since that result isn't particularly meaningful, it's NOT in the original report, as opposed to all the other numbers in the article.